Zakat-Eligibility Triage
Back to the queue

Clear the Haddad family's winter heating arrears 2

Platform category, as the organizer selected it
Emergency Relief
Stated goal
1850.00 CAD
Organizer
Suleyman Kiani, Hamilton, Ontario
Declared relationship to the beneficiary
Neighbour
Submitted
2026-09-03

Campaign story

Assalamu alaikum. My neighbour Abu Yusuf Haddad owes 1,850 CAD to the utility company after his delivery contract ended in June. The disconnection notice arrived last week and we have seen it, along with the account statement showing the arrears. He has found part-time work starting next month, but the arrears are due now and the family has nothing left after rent. Every dollar raised goes to the utility account directly. May Allah reward you.

The agent's file

Who wrote what you are about to read:

  • MODEL PROSEwritten by the model in its own words. Not a quotation of any source, and not to be read as one.
  • CORPUS TEXTrecorded reference data, human-authored and versioned, shown word for word under the id it is stored by.
  • CAMPAIGN QUOTEa verbatim span of the organizer's own story, with the offsets it occupies.

Read by claude-sonnet-5 on 2026-09-03 10:32 UTC, against policy 60fb3a0adfe7. This file decides nothing.

Refusal

The pipeline did not refuse. Nothing to deliver: the pipeline did not refuse.

What the text says about each category

al-fuqara (the poor)

Supported by the text
MODEL PROSE

The story states that after paying rent the household has nothing left, indicating an inability to meet other basic needs such as the utility bill.

CAMPAIGN QUOTE

the family has nothing left after rent.

characters 331 to 370 of the story

al-masakin (the needy)

Supported by the text
MODEL PROSE

The story states the household has nothing left after rent, a subsistence-level detail showing the family cannot cover the remaining basic need of the utility bill.

CAMPAIGN QUOTE

the family has nothing left after rent.

characters 331 to 370 of the story

al-amilina-alayha (those employed to administer it)

Not supported by the text
MODEL PROSE

The story states that every dollar raised goes directly to the utility account, which points away from any administrative or collection deduction being taken from the funds.

al-muallafati-qulubuhum (those whose hearts are to be reconciled)

Not supported by the text
MODEL PROSE

The story does not engage this category.

fi-al-riqab (freeing those in bondage)

Not supported by the text
MODEL PROSE

The story does not engage this category.

al-gharimin (those in debt)

Supported by the text
MODEL PROSE

The story names the utility company as creditor, states the amount owed, explains the debt arose after the delivery contract ended, and says the arrears are due now.

CAMPAIGN QUOTE

owes 1,850 CAD to the utility company after his delivery contract ended in June.

characters 48 to 128 of the story
CAMPAIGN QUOTE

the arrears are due now

characters 303 to 326 of the story

fi-sabilillah (in the path of God)

Not supported by the text
MODEL PROSE

The story does not engage this category.

ibn-al-sabil (the wayfarer)

Not supported by the text
MODEL PROSE

The story does not engage this category.

What to ask the organizer

Nothing was left unresolved for want of a fact the organizer could supply.

Files a new agent file. The one above is kept, and any decision already taken against it keeps pointing at what its reviewer read.

Precedent

Previously adjudicated campaigns, closest first. Every one of them is synthetic and written for this repository. They are here for you to compare against and they decide nothing: the decision on this campaign is yours to record.

None of this section was shown to the model that read the campaign. See ADR-0004 for why.

Clearing a hospital bill for the Nasser family

Approved

on 2026-01-27

My uncle Bilal spent eleven weeks in hospital in Amman after a fall at work and came home to an invoice for 6,800 JOD. The hospital has sent two payment demands and the last one gives us until the end of next month. He is 61, he has not worked since the fall, and the family has no savings left after the first surgery....

al-fuqarasupportedal-masakininsufficient evidenceal-ghariminsupported

Approved. The itemised invoice and both payment demands were supplied, so the debt is current and quantified rather than anticipated, and that is the fact our policy asks for first. The household's own means do not cover it on the statements we were sent. I asked the organizer directly whether any part of the balance is accrued interest or a late charge and was told it is not, which the invoice bears out. Payment goes to the beneficiary, who settles the account. Straightforward on the evidence; the only reason it took a second look is that a medical bill is often a bill someone else is already paying, and here nobody is.

Recorded by the reviewer who decided this case

Rent arrears for a widowed mother of three

Approved

on 2026-02-19

I am raising 2,400 GBP for my sister Halima, who has been raising three children on her own since her husband died in February. She works part time in a school kitchen and the hours were cut in September. Her income does not cover the rent and the heating in the same month, and she is now four months behind with a...

al-fuqarasupportedal-masakinsupportedal-gharimininsufficient evidence

Approved for zakat. The organizer supplied three months of bank statements for every account and the tenancy agreement, and our team read them: on the figures given, net assets sit well below the threshold our policy uses and the arrears are documented rather than asserted. Funds are paid to the beneficiary rather than to the landlord's agent, which is what our policy requires. I left al-gharimin as unresolved rather than counting the arrears twice; nothing turns on it here because the household qualifies on need alone. No scholarly question arose and no consultation was needed.

Recorded by the reviewer who decided this case

Transit and shelter for a family displaced by flooding

Approved

on 2025-10-09

The Anwar family left their village in the last week of August when the water reached the roof of their house. They are now in a school hall two provinces away with what they carried. Their land and their stored rice are under water and they cannot reach either, and the bus fare back plus three months of rented rooms...

al-fuqarainsufficient evidenceal-masakinsupportedibn-al-sabilsupported

Approved. This is the shape our policy describes under the wayfarer heading: people away from home and cut off from assets they own but cannot reach, which is a different thing from owning nothing at all, and the copy is explicit about it. Registration papers were supplied and checked. I noted for the file that applying this category to displaced people is a reading our policy already takes and that our advisor signed off on this pattern of campaign last year, so I recorded the decision against that standing position rather than opening it again. Their land is not evidence against need here; it is precisely what they cannot reach. Worth saying plainly for the next reviewer: some platforms decline to verify traveller cases at all, on the practical ground that a genuinely stranded person is unlikely to be running a campaign. That is a workable position and it is not ours. We verify them where the displacement is documented, which is our board's choice about operating risk rather than anything scholars are divided on, and a reviewer who finds the documentation thin should say so rather than lean on the category being permitted.

Recorded by the reviewer who decided this case

A support fund for people new to the community

Information requested

on 2026-07-23

Most people who take shahadah at our centre never come back after the second month. Some are not on speaking terms with their families, some have moved out with a bag, and almost none of them know anyone. We are raising 25,000 GBP for a two-year support fund: a mentor for the first year, weekly classes, a shared meal...

al-fuqarainsufficient evidencefi-sabilillahinsufficient evidenceal-muallafati-qulubuhuminsufficient evidence

Information requested, after I put it to our advisor. Whether this category still operates at all is genuinely disputed between contemporary bodies, and one of them moved on it as recently as this year, so our policy does not let a badge rest on that question by itself. The question I put to the advisor was about our own policy rather than about the underlying difference, and the answer was to look for an independent basis in the campaign. So I have asked the organizer what share of the fund is emergency grants going to individuals, and whether those recipients are in material need at the point they receive it, since that would put part of this campaign somewhere I can assess on evidence. None of this is a finding against the organizer or against the category, and I said so in the message, because a request that reads as a soft refusal will not get me the facts I need.

Recorded by the reviewer who decided this case

Decision

Your decision, which is the one that counts
Typed rather than taken from a session, because this prototype has no authentication.
Required. A decision with no reasoning behind it cannot be reviewed later, and the database will not store one.

Audit trail

  1. Approved by Ali Shah, 2026-09-03 07:07 UTC

    Against agent file run_63effb50-3bd7-4eab-896e-a4add000595e. Agreed with the agent file

    Suleyman Kiani